Post by james55703 on Jun 27, 2004 15:50:06 GMT -5
SOME NEW THOUGHTS.
After thinking through many, many things regarding CMKX, I've reached some new directions on thinking. I base these thoughts on three key assumptions. Anyone who disagrees with these assumptions will obviously disagree with everything I say. Which is fine. I'm not here to convince anyone of anything. I'm here to share my thoughts and you can either agree or disagree but a) I don't care, and b) your agreement or disagreement won't affect the ultimate outcome of this stock anyway. So here are my three assumptions and the basis for each, then I will get into where I'm going with this.
Assumption 1:
There is a very large short position. My estimate is 100 billion. You either agree or disagree. Based on trading volume in the past year, that is my opinion.
Assumption 2:
The O/S share count is around 10 billion. Urban retired billions of shares last year. It is documented in press releases. 36.5 billion were retired between September and December in '03. I believe he was doing this for a reason. Obviously, you cannot be a successful public company with 100 billion shares. He was making a legitimate effort to take this number down to something palatable. Something investors could actually live with. We have not seen any updates on the retiring of shares, but we have seen Roger Glenn hired. I believe when Urban had everything in order with a palatable number of outstanding shares, he then approached Roger. I am choosing 10 billion and erring on the side of what I believe is conservative. It's entirely possible that Urban retired enough to take this down to under 1 billion. Who knows. I will choose conservatively and assume 10 billion.
Assumption 3:
I am guessing that when all the geology is completed and we perhaps have some further drilling results back, that we will be looking at mining potential in the range of $20-30 billion. I believe that is a very conservative estimate. I think many people are underestimating the true reach of this latest PR. This number could be as high as $100 billion+ in my opinion but I will conservatively say $20-30 billion.
Now, if at this point you are rolling your eyes and in complete disagreement with anything I've said above, then please stop reading. I really don't care if you disagree with nice personumptions. These are MY thoughts and I'm allowed to have them. Much of what follows has some basis in Sterling's thoughts over on Raging Bull, which at first I thought were pretty wild, but then I began thinking them through more and more.
So my new thinking over the weekend is that I've become much fonder of the notion of a tender offer by Urban to go private. One thing that has always baffled me in this whole mix is that if they let the short covering just play itself out straight out, the results are wildly unpredictable. It is entirely possible that enough people will sell to allow the short off the hook by maybe 5 cents or 10 cents. But then again it's possible that there will be such a massive buying frenzy, that the shorts won't even be close at that point. When the sharks circle, it gets VICIOUS. It's possible that this could indeed become the mother of all squeezes reaching several dollars, maybe even in the double digits. Depending on the size of the short position, when you start getting into numbers like that, you have what I would term "chaos". Market regulators don't like chaos. And nobody likes market regulators.
So I began thinking about what the options would be to prevent complete chaos and still deliver what everyone wants. I keep coming back to the same conclusion that a tender offer to go private would be the quickest, safest, easiest method to lock in a price that burns the shorts but not the entire market, makes all the shareholders happy and does not leave anything up to chances as to how this will all resolve itself. It basically names a price and that's that. SEC can't do anything about it. DTC can't do anything about it. Shorts can't do anything about it. If Urban has the financial backing, he has every right to make a tender offer.
So now we get to tender offers. What is fair value for a tender offer. Well, in my opinion first off Urban needs financial backing to extend a tender offer. He's going to have come up with the money to make the offer. Of course, if he owns 9 billion out of the 10 billion shares left, he doesn't have to come up with the money to fund those 9 billion shares since he would, in effect, be paying himself. But unless he owns the ENTIRE float (possible given the short situation), he may still need some money. Roger just happens to be a top attorney at a law firm with perhaps the finest collection of private equity financing clients in the country. Moreover, if a true value can be attached to this property, Urban may qualify for some significant debt financing with a major bank/institution in order to perform the buyout and go private. I think Roger is here for more than just paperwork filing.
The thing that I like about the tender offer approach is that it makes everyone happy. We get a presumably nice buyout price. The shorts get torched but not in a way that the market crumbles. Urban gets his company back and can now turn around and do an IPO as a new entity to achieve proper market valuation.
After thinking through many, many things regarding CMKX, I've reached some new directions on thinking. I base these thoughts on three key assumptions. Anyone who disagrees with these assumptions will obviously disagree with everything I say. Which is fine. I'm not here to convince anyone of anything. I'm here to share my thoughts and you can either agree or disagree but a) I don't care, and b) your agreement or disagreement won't affect the ultimate outcome of this stock anyway. So here are my three assumptions and the basis for each, then I will get into where I'm going with this.
Assumption 1:
There is a very large short position. My estimate is 100 billion. You either agree or disagree. Based on trading volume in the past year, that is my opinion.
Assumption 2:
The O/S share count is around 10 billion. Urban retired billions of shares last year. It is documented in press releases. 36.5 billion were retired between September and December in '03. I believe he was doing this for a reason. Obviously, you cannot be a successful public company with 100 billion shares. He was making a legitimate effort to take this number down to something palatable. Something investors could actually live with. We have not seen any updates on the retiring of shares, but we have seen Roger Glenn hired. I believe when Urban had everything in order with a palatable number of outstanding shares, he then approached Roger. I am choosing 10 billion and erring on the side of what I believe is conservative. It's entirely possible that Urban retired enough to take this down to under 1 billion. Who knows. I will choose conservatively and assume 10 billion.
Assumption 3:
I am guessing that when all the geology is completed and we perhaps have some further drilling results back, that we will be looking at mining potential in the range of $20-30 billion. I believe that is a very conservative estimate. I think many people are underestimating the true reach of this latest PR. This number could be as high as $100 billion+ in my opinion but I will conservatively say $20-30 billion.
Now, if at this point you are rolling your eyes and in complete disagreement with anything I've said above, then please stop reading. I really don't care if you disagree with nice personumptions. These are MY thoughts and I'm allowed to have them. Much of what follows has some basis in Sterling's thoughts over on Raging Bull, which at first I thought were pretty wild, but then I began thinking them through more and more.
So my new thinking over the weekend is that I've become much fonder of the notion of a tender offer by Urban to go private. One thing that has always baffled me in this whole mix is that if they let the short covering just play itself out straight out, the results are wildly unpredictable. It is entirely possible that enough people will sell to allow the short off the hook by maybe 5 cents or 10 cents. But then again it's possible that there will be such a massive buying frenzy, that the shorts won't even be close at that point. When the sharks circle, it gets VICIOUS. It's possible that this could indeed become the mother of all squeezes reaching several dollars, maybe even in the double digits. Depending on the size of the short position, when you start getting into numbers like that, you have what I would term "chaos". Market regulators don't like chaos. And nobody likes market regulators.
So I began thinking about what the options would be to prevent complete chaos and still deliver what everyone wants. I keep coming back to the same conclusion that a tender offer to go private would be the quickest, safest, easiest method to lock in a price that burns the shorts but not the entire market, makes all the shareholders happy and does not leave anything up to chances as to how this will all resolve itself. It basically names a price and that's that. SEC can't do anything about it. DTC can't do anything about it. Shorts can't do anything about it. If Urban has the financial backing, he has every right to make a tender offer.
So now we get to tender offers. What is fair value for a tender offer. Well, in my opinion first off Urban needs financial backing to extend a tender offer. He's going to have come up with the money to make the offer. Of course, if he owns 9 billion out of the 10 billion shares left, he doesn't have to come up with the money to fund those 9 billion shares since he would, in effect, be paying himself. But unless he owns the ENTIRE float (possible given the short situation), he may still need some money. Roger just happens to be a top attorney at a law firm with perhaps the finest collection of private equity financing clients in the country. Moreover, if a true value can be attached to this property, Urban may qualify for some significant debt financing with a major bank/institution in order to perform the buyout and go private. I think Roger is here for more than just paperwork filing.
The thing that I like about the tender offer approach is that it makes everyone happy. We get a presumably nice buyout price. The shorts get torched but not in a way that the market crumbles. Urban gets his company back and can now turn around and do an IPO as a new entity to achieve proper market valuation.